top of page

Tips To Make An Effective Peer Review

What is a peer review?

It is a process of evaluating the research work (Thesis writing, Dissertation writing, Manuscript writing etc) of the scholars or academic students (review) by the people (peer) who are specialists in the particular genre. Prior to publication each and every research paper is properly reviewed by a reviewer’s board. The reviewers will try to examine whether the research methods are used properly or not, the importance of researcher’ acknowledgment for using other researchers’ contribution (citations).

Peer Review

Tips for peer review

1. React quickly

  • Whenever a scholar requests to make peer review, firstly check whether it is related to your specialized subject. If it comes under your field then start with the further proceedings for better improvement or else simply inform them about your specialization so, that they can approach other experts.

2. Upkeep reliability

  • The document submitted for reviewing must be kept confidential. The reviewer has the responsibility to preserve data from a research paper. Trustworthiness is the important element to stay as a peer reviewer.

  • Take maximum time to examine their work and dedicate your costly time to repay their trust.

3. Supportive feedback

  • All your comments must be constructive to the scholar for enhancing their paper, consequently, your comments ought to be in a professional way.

  • If you have doubt in their research works ask explanation from the particular person or group or else simply approach your senior to know more. This reflects your quality of knowledge and education.

  • All the recommendations and pinpointed comments must be ordered properly, as a result, it helps the scholars to properly decode the suitable information for it.

  • It is not necessary to only spot technical error also you could appreciate them for the valuable data and methods used in their research work. By doing so, you will increase the confidence level of the researcher.

4. Stay in the lane

  • Your proposals should stay within their research idea and don’t confuse or drift them with unnecessary information.

  • Checking grammatical errors in the paper is not the work of a reviewer, but definitely, you may suggest them for using other words if any particular word or line differs from the research context.

Each peer review must do their best to improve the quality of papers by encouraging the scholars with effective recommendations. So the researchers will become aware of their mistake and submit well-qualified paper because almost every researcher is considering the peer-reviewed paper as a trustable source and reliable data for using in their present and further research. The main purpose of submitting a research paper to peer review is only to improve the research effectiveness so all the activities of a peer reviewer must satisfy it.


Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page